med-img

GDC 10: EA Sports Fine Tuning Design Based on User Data

Posted March 9, 2010 by James Brightman

[IndustryGamers would like to thank EA Sports for sponsoring our trip to GDC this year]

_ _

IndustryGamers attended a special EA Sports “Season Opener” during the Game Developers conference, where the publisher showed off games like Tiger Woods PGA Tour 11, EA Sports MMA, EA Sports Active 2.0, EA Sports Active More Workouts, 2010 FIFA World Cup South Africa, and more. While we enjoyed checking out the games, the most interesting part of the evening came during a presentation by EA Tiburon GM Philip Holt who outlined the massive amounts of online data that EA actually analyzes to fine tune its games, like the next NCAA Football or Madden.

Holt noted that people are so consumed with all sorts of media, especially the “millenials” generation on the web, that it can be hard to ask them to carve out a whole hour of time to play an EA Sports video game, which is about how long it takes to complete a game in Madden NFL 10. “One of the key things we've been driving to is creating shorter consumable experiences in the world of Madden, NCAA and other titles,” he said.

Holt also stressed how EA Sports is engaging the hardcore on the web, particularly by paying attention to user feedback on forums. He cited the example of how pass rush in Madden NFL 10 last year in the lead-up to the game wasn't working properly and there were complaints across a number of forums. EA Sports isolated the problem, posted a detailed explanation (and a video) on forums like Operation Sports, and quickly fixed the issue in the game.

Responding quickly to fans on message boards and fixing problems in games is one thing, but the real advantage of the connected gaming era is that EA Sports has access to an absolutely huge amount of user data, which it can then examine to fine tune game design elements for the next iteration. EA Sports found that 82% of the NCAA audience and 76% of the Madden audience connect to the web with the games. “We have this ability now to really understand what they're doing with our products in a way that's unlike any time in the history of our franchises and that's led to some interesting insights,” Holt said.

Roy Harvey, executive producer on NCAA Football, who's been with EA since 2003, then took the stage to elaborate on Holt's point and cite some specific examples. Harvey said 30 million games have been played in NCAA already this year – 80% have been in dynasty mode and a good portion have been in online dynasty mode. He said that most of these folks are also connected online through social media, and that's going to be a “big part” of what EA Sports does going forward.

Next up, to talk specifically about how crucial feedback and online user data is to the Madden franchise, Jeremy Strauser, executive producer for Madden, grabbed the mic. While input from licensors, John Madden himself and EA Sports president Peter Moore is all quite helpful to the Madden team, the best feedback comes from real-world data from the gamers; after all, these are the folks buying and playing the game, so catering to the consumers buying the product is obviously a smart move. Strauser noted that the system to track real-time data usage from players was put in place back in 2004 in Madden, and since that time players have become much more web connected, so EA Sports has already benefited from the online system to analyze gamers' habits and address design issues over the years in the franchise. In fact, Strauser said they get over 173 million data instances every day on Madden, so the company has a dedicated team to aggregate and make sense of all that data.

For example, one fun fact, which makes light of Brett Favre's infamous playoff interception pass, is that among Madden users he's thrown over 7.5 million interceptions. More meaningful than that, however, is data on gameplay elements, like stiff arming, for instance. EA Sports wanted to make sure that using a stiff arm in Madden was not “too effective,” and the data showed that the design played out among users just how the developers had wanted. Over 300 million stiff arms were attempted, but just 23% of them were successful, which is in line with the team's goal of around 25%. On the other hand, looking at another game mechanic, the hit stick (flipping the right analog stick to cause a big hit), EA Sports found the gameplay wasn't quite tuned right. It's supposed to be a high risk, high reward element, but the data showed a 46% success rate among users, which was just not risky enough. So the gameplay team was able to go back and re-tune and test that and deploy it (via downloadable update) a month after release. 

These are just a couple examples of how tracking usage data can be extremely helpful to EA Sports when looking to improve the experience for players right after launch or to make bigger adjustments for the next release a year later. Thanks to the online, connected era developers can get instant feedback, and it's a method that any design team ought to leverage. EA Sports is already analyzing tons of user data to make sure the next NCAA and Madden titles outperform their predecessors. And if you're a hardcore gamer, it's pretty cool to know that EA Sports is evaluating your gameplay to make design adjustments. So go ahead and fire up Madden 10, and in doing so you just might help make Madden 11 better for all of us.

James Brightman has been covering the games industry since 2003 and has been an avid gamer ever since the days of Atari and Intellivision. He was previously the EIC of GameDaily Biz.

21 Comments

iib241
May 5, 2010

It may even come close to beating it if they push hard enough. And no one has better commercials than Sony. Especially Microsoft. online fax machine

iib241
May 9, 2010

It may even come close to beating it if they push hard enough. And no one has better commercials than Sony. Especially Microsoft. online fax

iib241
May 13, 2010

they have to sign the standard distribution deal to get the game published then they still end up handing over more money to the publisher/distributor.online fax

emogurl12
May 16, 2010

I will never actually own these games because they are stored on their "Clouds" and I gurantee there will be no discount passed on to the consumer for the money the publisher is saving. NO THANKS.
best internet fax service

pravi
May 17, 2010

The more likely scenario (as detailed above) is that the Wii gets replaced and Nintendo starts over with "Wii HD" or whatever; Nintendo has denied it up and down, so we'll just have to wait and see if it happens.fax from internet

zouzou44
May 20, 2010

The more likely scenario (as detailed above) is that the Wii gets replaced and Nintendo starts over with "Wii HD" or whatever; Nintendo has denied it up and down, so we'll just have to wait and see if it happens. online fax

zouzou44
May 20, 2010

But you have to admit ALL god of war games have OVER the TOP art. online fax

zouzou44
May 21, 2010

And thus why would the console manufacturers expend the massive resources needed to develop a new console when their capacity to get return on that investment has been drastically curtailed?


Canvas Art

sam25
May 25, 2010

In other words I think there attempts at change is getting in the way. The more square changes the less you seem to care about each character.ecommerce host

ravi15
May 27, 2010

The more likely scenario (as detailed above) is that the Wii gets replaced and Nintendo starts over with "Wii HD" or whatever; Nintendo has denied it up and down, so we'll just have to wait and see if it happens. identity theft service reviews

peter
May 30, 2010

Nothing about what I said was muddled.
best identity theft services

tomcruze55
May 30, 2010

Several blog search engines are used to search blog contents, such as Bloglines, BlogScope, and Technorati. Technorati, which is among the most popular blog search engines, provides current information on both popular searches and tags used to categorize blog postings. convert email to fax

jack40
May 31, 2010

he Remote of Windows 7 is also enhanced to support real-time multimedia application including video playback and 3D games, thus allowing use of DirectX 10 in remote desktop environments. top ecommerce hosting

healthinsurance
June 9, 2010

FIFA Soccer 11 reinvents player authenticity -- on and off the ball -- for every player and at every position on the pitch with Personality+, an all-new feature that sees individual abilities reflected in game, enabling clear differentiation for every player.
Facebook Login

james123
June 11, 2010

I have no fundamental problem with Green Day: Rock Band. I just don't care. They are a fine group and I casually enjoy some, if not many, of their songs, but it's more a situation of not changing the channel on the car radio if American Idiot or Good Riddance comes on. identity theft crime

Rosa22
June 13, 2010

The levels start out fairly easy, the first 10 are basically a tutorial for the various abilities of your robot and the obstacles he will face.html email marketing software

youpi33
June 20, 2010

he continued, “We’ve always wanted the community to guide the vision of the platform.”compare email marketing software

zombi
June 25, 2010

Many Americans are ignorant and clueless about what the government is doing in other countries in the name of America.
american roulette table layout

zombi
June 27, 2010

They are a fine group and I casually enjoy some, if not many, of their songs, but it's more a situation of not changing the channel on the car radio if American Idiot or Good Riddance comes on.
Tent with Trailer

fairytales
June 27, 2010

The easiest way to play an electronic sports match is over the Internet. General online play is subject to the lessened ability to detect cheating and the more unpredictable network latency not being the ideal environment for high level competition; however, due to its convenience, even players who are used to LAN games use Internet games for fun and exhibition game.shopping cart solutions

fairytales
June 29, 2010

Fantasy it is suitable (and proven) to provide a framework for all sorts of fantasies people have. Well, you cannot be astronaut. Star Wars, in my opinion, works the same way.inflatable boats